S.C. Statehouse Report
Sunday, Feb. 18, 2007
VIEW: http://www.statehousereport.com/columns/07.0218.voucher.htm

Keep public school dollars in public domain
By Andy Brack, Publisher

FEB. 18, 2007 -- To confuse an enemy, an octopus squirts black ink in the water and scoots away.

To confuse a political enemy, a politician often attaches a new name to a something to stir up support for something that hasn't been too popular with its real name.

Such is the case with school choice.

These days, the tune has changed for a lot of the folks who just a few years ago promoted the concept of school vouchers to allow parents to use public money to send their kids to private school. Now they talk about "school choice."

They get mad if you use the term "voucher." They say their policy position is all about giving parents "choices" about whether to send their kids to private school or keep them in public school. They say tax credits are needed to allow parents to make this choice. And they call for "tuition reimbursements" - - a new name for vouchers - - so poor students can leave low-rated public schools for private schools.

In fact, the old "Put Parents In Charge" proposal has been replaced by the "South Carolina Educational Opportunity Scholarship Act."

Behind the rhetoric is this core value - - these folks want to steer public tax dollars to pay for private school education. Whether it's a voucher, scholarship, reimbursement or tax credit, it would shift money from the public good into private school coffers.

Meanwhile, folks like State Superintendent Jim Rex are pushing for real school choice - - more choices among public schools for parents. He's barnstorming with a plan that would expand public school options with new types of schools and allow students to transfer to any public school in the state.

"My fear is public school choice alone isn't going to help someone surrounded by failing public schools," said Rep. Tracy Edge, the GOP House member who is lead sponsor of the new tax credit/voucher push. Last year, the plan died by a handful of votes in the S.C. House.

Edge, who says Rex's ideas are a step in the right direction, admitted this year's school proposal isn't much different from last year's. It calls for a $1,000 tax credit for families who send kids to private school, a $500 tax credit for home-schooled students and a $4,500 "tuition reimbursement" for poor students to leave low-rated schools for private schools.

If approved, the proposal would have a big budgetary impact. With about 53,000 students in private schools and 15,000 being home schooled, the state could lose up to $60 million in revenue if everyone who qualified for the tax credit took it. And that's not even considering anyone who might take the $4,500 voucher.

$60 million ain't chicken feed. It's enough to buy a $100 laptop for just about every kid in public schools across the state. It's enough to pay for 1,400 new teachers to lower class sizes across the state.


We encourage your feedback. If you'd like to respond to something in SC Statehouse Report, please send us an e-mail. We reserve the right to edit for length and clarity. One submission allowed per month. Submission of a comment grants permission to us to reprint. Please keep your comment to 250 words or less:


Edge said he felt there was momentum again with his tax credit bill. In part, that's because Gov. Mark Sanford has re-emerged from the closet he went in last year to get away from the issue in an election year. It's also because some lawmakers are frightened because Sanford and his cronies wielded some power in GOP primaries last year by backing candidates who supported the voucher/tax credit concept and beat recalcitrant Republican House members who didn't.

Regardless of whether political momentum is building over so-called school choice, it would be bad public policy for South Carolina to back any tax credit measure to use public tax dollars to support private schools.

As a practical matter, you could drive a hole through logic surrounding the proposal. For anyone who believes in "market forces," smart private schools will simply raise tuition $1,000 and parents will be stuck with paying the same thing with the dang tax credit.

Also there's the market itself. Many private schools aren't for the credits or vouchers because they know the current private school system just can't handle a huge influx of new students. Rex added a voucher system would attract fly-by-night educators who start new schools and promise the world to parents but don't deliver. It's the education equivalent of bad contractors who flocked to Charleston after Hurricane Hugo.

Finally, there's a simple matter of fairness, as Rex explained: "If the state starts to incentivize people to leave the public schools, it will make us more separate and unequal in the long run."

Public dollars for education need to stay in the public domain and not be used for private education.

You can read the full report by MDC Inc. at www.mdcinc.com. You can reach Andy Brack, publisher of S.C. Statehouse Report, at brack@statehousereport.com.

Recent commentary

lighter side
Valentine's Scrooge

Another great cartoon from Bill McLemore:

Recent feedback

The best way to get South Carolina news is to augment your morning paper and TV show with SC Clips, a daily executive news summary compiled from more than 30 state newspaper and TV sources. It's delivered every business day and is packed with news of statewide impact, politics, business and more. Subscriptions are affordable at $30 per month -- and less for business subscribers. More: SC Clips.

How you can subscribe to the full edition of the report

The above version of S.C. Statehouse Report is the free edition. Our paid version, which costs about $100 per month, offer a weekly legislative forecast packed with information that can keep you and your business on the cutting edge. There's a new limited paid version for individuals that costs about $30 per month. More on subscribing.

Notes veteran lawmaker Sen. Glenn McConnell: "Statehouse Report gives an inside practical report of weekly problems with and progress of legislation. It reviews the whole landscape."

In each issue of Statehouse Report, you'll get:

  • Hot news -- an early peek on something really big that will happen at the Statehouse. We continually beat other news organizations in finding major trends in issues, from teacher and budget cuts to wetlands proposals.
  • Agenda -- a weekly forecast of the coming week's floor agenda
  • Radar Screen -- a behind-the-scenes look at what's really going on in the General Assembly
  • Palmetto Politics -- Tidbits from the world of South Carolina politics.
  • McLemore's World -- an early view of our respected cartoonist Bill McLemore.
  • Tally Sheet -- a weekly review of all of the new bills introduced in the legislature in everyday language
  • Blogroll -- a weekly summary of the best of South Carolina political blogs.
  • Scorecard -- A Thumbs Up and Thumbs Down of major political/policy events for the week.
  • Calendar -- a weekly list of major meetings for the House, Senate and state agencies.
  • Megaphone -- a quote of the week that you'll find illuminating.

To learn more about subscriptions, contact Andy Brack at: brack@statehousereport.com


South Carolina Statehouse Report

Publisher: Andy Brack
Editor: Bill Davis | Assistant Editor: Betsy Brack

Phone: 843.670.3996 Fax: 843.722.9887

Subscription or sponsorship Inquiries: info@statehousereport.com

Have an event for the SC Statehouse Report calendar? E-mail details to: news@statehousereport.com or fax to above number.

For additional information, including subscription prices, go to http://www.statehousereport.com/.

Just a quick note to let you know how you missed out this week. If you were a subscriber to the paid edition of Statehouse Report, you would have received the information below on Friday AND you would have gotten other special features:

  • NUMBER OF THE WEEK: $210,000
  • NEWS: Waiting game on for protecting isolated wetlands
  • LEGISLATIVE AGENDA: Reform and virtual schools
  • RADAR SCREEN: House committee to take up budget
  • PALMETTO POLITICS: Believability Index
  • PHOTO: Important shadow
  • TALLY SHEET: Recently-introduced legislation
  • SCORECARD: Ups and downs of the past week
  • MEGAPHONE: Holding back

For more information, contact us today about our affordable paid subscriptions for businesses and organizations that need the inside scoop at the Statehouse.

D-HEC with it
From the paid-subscriber issue of Statehouse Report

FEB. 16, 2007 -- For the past three legislative sessions, [Sen. Larry] Grooms, the chairman of his body's Agriculture and Natural Resources Committee, has worked to create a bill to regulate and manage the state's many isolated wetlands - small bodies of water without a visible river, stream or ditch physically connecting them to another body of water..

  • If you subscribed to the full edition of Statehouse Report, you'd get more information on this and much more. Contact us today to learn more.

AVAILABLE NOW: Furman University's Don Gordon has great things to say about Andy Brack's new book of commentaries, "Bugging the Palmettos." Click here to learn more and buy the book -- only $15.00!

Visit Statehouse Report


A blog on ideas and news that is for Southern policy leaders, analysts and more.


  Copyright 2007, Statehouse Report LLC, which is affiliated with The Brack Group, Charleston, S.C.
Reproduction is prohibited without express permission of the publisher. For additional information, including subscription prices, go to